Scammers all the way down and why trust matters
One of my favorite stories for my kids when they were little was about Yertle the Turtle, and his stack of turtles. The story is really about hubris and how important the king turtle was on the top of the stack, until one turtle, Mack, decided to stop holding up everyone else. Of course, this is built on an older legend about how the Earth was supported in space. The concept was that we rode on the back of a turtle. The next logical question was - what holds up the turtle? It's turtles all the way down was the answer.
In our economy, and in capitalism generally, one of the critical foundation blocks that makes capitalism and our political economy work is trust. We trust that the goods and services we acquire will work as advertised. We trust that when we pay for goods and services not yet rendered, that they will be delivered on time and as promised. We trust that our politicians will represent our interests and disclose any conflicts. Without trust, our highly integrated, distributed and fast paced economy becomes more sluggish, requires more investigation and accreditation and ultimately becomes a barter economy.
It's scammers all the way down
Bloomberg.com just ran a series of articles on the concerns and issues associated with scams. My parents have stopped answering their phones because every second call is a scammer, trying to obtain their personal data or sell them products or services they don't need. The energy that goes into phishing and ransomware, if redirected to positive outcomes, could probably improve the quality of life for a significant number of people and countries.
Make no mistake, scammers have existed for centuries, making money off of people who were too naive and too trusting to dig deeply into their offers. What's difficult now with scammers is the ability to create audio and video with AI, that appears to be real. It's gotten to the point where I have given my relatives a safe word for phone calls. If they have questions about whether or not it's me calling, all they have to do is ask for the safe word. No more calls from their "grandson" in jail in Nicaragua who needs $10K to leave the country.
What comes from a lack of trust
What these scammers do is chip away at our rights and responsibilities as citizens, as business people and as consumers. We have a right to privacy, embedded in the Constitution. They have rights to free speech, as long as it is not harmful. We have a difficult balancing act between maintaining free and effective speech and communications while protecting ourselves, our customers and our loved ones from outright attacks on their persons, especially their personal data.
When businesses act in a way that reduces trust, most consumers seek assurance or insurance to defend themselves. When scammers and criminals use scams to obtain information or money, we seek stronger laws and more severe punishments. What do we do when our governments actively work to sow doubt and discord in the population? Isn't a lack of political trust as damaging as a lack of economic trust? After all, our economic viability is supported and maintained by our political trust. Without a strong political framework to guarantee our rights, our economic viability becomes questionable.
When our leaders suggest that we need new facts, or that the media only publishes "fake news", it introduces doubt and discord. When AI can create very meaningful scams that mimic business leaders or political figures, people are likely to question every pronouncement or decision. When our representatives can trade on data before it becomes available to the public, we are right to wonder who has our best interests at heart.
All of these things and more contribute to a lack of trust, of trust in neighbors, in family members, in businesses, in the media, in our political establishment. And as trust falters, we become susceptible to distrust, to looking for new solutions or bedrock truths, or to new charlatans who promise new solutions or new truths. We become fragmented, indecisive and unwilling to take risks, not ready to trust that the venture is honest or can be successful.
When we lose our creative spark, concerned about whether we can trust our inventors, investors, neighbors or politicians, we become more tribal, more self-centered and take fewer risks. We spend more, often unnecessarily, on ensuring the risks we take are mitigated. Our economy is weaker when trust is at a minimum.
Let's flip the narrative
What's strange is that for every story or insinuation where people or institutions call factors into question, where is a corresponding answer, and it is often based in the same systems. For example, when politicians call voting patterns into question, or insinuate that voting is "rigged", we can be assured of two things. First, there is almost always some chicanery in voting. Otherwise, we wouldn't have the saying about voting early and often in Chicago. But this chicanery isn't new and isn't widespread and often hurts only the people in the locality. But second, most of these allegations can be proven or disproven by data. For example, the recent news that 400 people voted illegally in New Jersey. The governor there had commented that there were no signs of voting irregularity, which boggles the mind. Every election has some irregularity to it. The real question is whether or not the irregularity is widespread, observable and has a direct impact on the outcome. In a state like New Jersey, where millions of people vote, 400 votes is unlikely to sway any election. As long as humans program the voting machines, there will be some bias and some error coded into the machines. Just as umpires do an excellent job calling balls and strikes but sometimes make a mistake, so do people in all roles and industries. The question isn't whether there could be gaps or exploitable opportunities, but whether or not they are easily available, material, exploited regularly, constantly ignored and have an impact on the outcome.
What we need to do, wherever possible, is let the data speak for itself. We need to go back to more transparency and more rule of law in government, we need to police our communications and track down, where possible, the scammers who make our day to day lives so fraught with uncertainty, and we need to use the same data and AI systems that create scams to defeat them.
Comments
Post a Comment