Ukraine: when faced with adversity, innovate

 It's a little funny, isn't it, to think that a country as dependent on Europe and the US for defense funding would become the place where virtually all modern militaries go to learn how to fight.  Three years ago, Ukraine seemed desperate, under direct attack by Russia, which had decided (and is still deciding) to deploy war in at least two dimensions - asymmetric against the civilian population, blowing up the electrical grid and targeting residential apartment buildings, seeking to sap the will of the Ukranian populace and attritional warfare, based on traditional Russian tactics from at least the Napoleonic wars, against the Ukrainian military.  Putin and his war counselors believe if they could drain the will to fight from the population and destroy the Ukrainian military on the ground by chewing them up in an attritional fight, they'd win easily.

Today, quite a different story emerges.  One can't help but reach for the old saw about fighting the last war, but Russian tactics would have won the day except for some timely intervention by Western forces which armed the Ukrainians, and the desperate innovation of the Ukrainians themselves.  Russia and its allies have enough manpower to eventually wear out and destroy the fighting capacity of the Ukraine, but there may not be enough will to fight in the Russian people or its economy.

Innovating when there is no other option

What's really dramatically different a few years on is what the Ukrainians have done with their strategic warfare.  In a sense, they have flipped the script on the Russians.  First, the Ukrainians are destabilizing the Russian populace by causing fuel shortages and demonstrating that no place in the Russian homeland is safe from attack.  Second, the Ukrainians, while short on manpower, are chewing up the Russians by defeating them with drones and robots at the front lines and denying the Russians the ability to rearm and resupply in the areas behind the front lines.  Basically, the Ukrainians have allowed the Russians to take the Donbas, but now the Russians can't really move forward and can't resupply.  And who knows what will happen in the Crimea.

But the really interesting question is:  how has the Ukraine done this?  How have they fought the world's second largest army to a standstill, in a region with no natural defenses, with a smaller army and with fewer weapons?  

There's a lesson to be learned here, about innovation and the freedom that comes from a lack of resources.

If you are seeking to fight a larger army, in a region where the ground is flat and has few natural defensive lines, where the enemy has more firepower and more men, when you have to beg, borrow or steal the defensive weapons you need, you have to get creative.  And that's what Ukraine has done.

Recognizing it needed to fight differently, the Ukraine has become the foremost authority on drone and robotic warfare.  Recently, I read about the first robotic/drone amphibious landing accomplished by a military.  It was done by the Ukrainians.  The Ukrainians have had to improvise and innovate because they had no other option.  Most militaries would spend years procuring designs and debating features of such a device.  The US military probably has plans for such a device, with the expectations of releasing it in five to ten years.  We aren't in the fight and we have plenty of options.  Pure innovation happens when there is an immediate need or threat, little investment and few options.  When these conditions exist, all ideas are good ideas, because there are so few of them.

What a true innovator receives

Let's not kid ourselves, however.  There were duds and setbacks in the rapid scaling of this autonomous drone army.  But the Ukrainians are learning and their OODA loop (read about John Boyd if you need the background) is running circles around the Russians.  The Ukrainians have learned more, and forgotten more, about drone and autonomous warfare than probably any other army on the planet.

They are reinvesting their successes and failures and building better, more sophisticated and more lethal autonomous weapons at a rate that is hard to match. Russian can't match it because of their rigid hierarchical structure, fear of failure and corruption.  The US can't match it because of the military industrial complex's defensiveness and the sloth in the procurement system, plus the fact that we have highly engineering (and highly expensive equipment) that can do the job, just not at the cost or pace of the Ukrainians.  So, everyone is learning from the Ukrainians.  At least I hope we are.

What this tells us about innovation generally

The Ukrainian military is the least likely place for innovation generally, since, like all militaries, it is wedded to past doctrine, is hierarchical and does not like change.  Most businesses are the same way.  But when confronted with what it considers an existential challenge, it manages to innovation exceptionally well.  This is why most corporate innovation never succeeds.  There is always a safer option, nothing is truly at stake, so why consider the rash or unusual ideas?  

But then, take it further.  Ukraine is successful not because it created one successful drone, but because it is creating new drones and autonomous options at an incredible rate, taking all of the learning and creating new weapons and systems, and getting exceptionally important data as to what works.  They are in a positive feedback loop that is accelerating.  Most corporations, fortunate enough to create one idea, will rest on the platitudes and milk that idea for all it is worth.



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

A peek at Trump's last two years

Executives: narrow your focus for success

The startup serenity prayer