Who on your team delivers value above AI replacement?

 Businesses face a whirlwind of change, perhaps none more important than understanding the capacity and capability of their workforce.  Covid sent us home and demonstrated that some could work remotely, without direct supervision.  A new generation of workers has entered the workforce, more focused on work-life balance and perhaps less gung-ho as previous generations.  AI has moved from a sideshow to a fully engaged complement in day-to-day activities.  These changes and more will require companies to understand a couple of important concepts about people in the workforce.  Those are:

 - Who is here to drive value and change, vs simply to punch the clock?

 - Who here can and will add significant value, versus who is here to claim a paycheck

 - Who are the people who add significant benefit beyond what AI can deliver?


As the workforce in many organizations becomes more disengaged (surveys show that engagement was falling before Covid and AI) and more work is done by robots, automated processes and AI, the real question is, who stands out, and will your culture allow them to stand out>

I think that every organization should be asking the following questions and identifying the people who are real standouts in these categories:

  • Who "thinks" for you?  I'm talking about thinking that creates new value, rather than those that scurry back to find out what ChatGPT tells them to think
  • Who fixes for you or creates improvements?  Typically, people are comfortable with work arounds and will not want to "rock the boat" where there are gaps or issues, or where an improvement can be made.  Who is regularly bringing not just problems but identified issues AND proposed fixes or improvements?
  • Who bleeds for you?  Who constantly reinforces the culture and behaviors that you want to see?
  • Who innovates for you?  Who is constantly bringing new ideas that can be converted into new products or services?
In an era when many people are disengaged, when AI is doing the thinking and work for your team and many employees are simply doing their 9 to 5 job, not seeking to go beyond their remit, you need, now more than ever, to find the people I've defined above.  Just like sports teams have a WAR metric (wins above replacement) which seeks to indicate which team members create value beyond a standard replacement, so too should you have metrics that indicate who is driving important and necessary behavior over their peers.  These are capabilities that AI cannot create.  Identifying and retaining the people who can deliver these values is critical.

Why this matters

The more AI does for us, the more we need to understand who the people are who can contribute above and beyond their AI replacement value.  Call it the VAAI metric - Value above AI replacement.

The challenge to identifying these people is that traditionally, people who raised questions, challenged assumptions, suggested fixes or new ideas were the ones who were ignored or sidelined, since corporate focus was on efficiency.  People who suggested fixes or innovations were often viewed as mavericks, not aligned with the pure processes and efficiency goals of the organization, seeking to disrupt proven processes.  Now, efficiency is still important and unfortunately overly emphasized in comp and culture, but speed and effectiveness is more important when it comes to evaluating the people who can best contribute.

As with all new technologies, cultural and compensation models are behind the adoption and implementation of new technologies.  We are acting as if we still have horses on the farm, when we now have powered tractors.  People and skills need to adapt, and we need to find the tractor drivers, not the people who groom horses, yet we are still emphasizing horse grooming.  In other words, fighting the last war when it comes to the skills and capabilities that matter most in how we think about and manage the workforce.  It's critical that you change how you think about your best performers and identify people who contribute more value, especially in categories where AI cannot.

Learning from sports

In the professional sports world, a metric similar to VAAI already exists.  It is called WAR - Wins Above Replacement.  The theory is that a team should consider what the value of a particular team member is and the benefit or cost of that team member versus the average.  So, you might ask:  what value does our 1st baseman (in baseball) contribute over the average of all the other 1st basemen in the league?  What would happen if we replaced him with the best 1st baseman in the league?  If a replacement would be better than what you currently have on the team, it would be calculated in Wins Above Replacement.  In other words, the replacement first baseman would play well enough to actually lead the team to more wins.

In the same regard, Value Above AI replacement would indicate which employees are adding value greater than what an average AI could do if AI could replace the role, and which employees are actually costing you more than an average AI replacement.  I can imagine in a few years we'll see HR teams actually stack ranking based on this kind of metric.

Mavericks wanted

Not everyone who raises issues or complaints is a maverick, but many people who suggest fixes, seek improvements, complain when the culture isn't followed are the people you need most right now.

These individuals have been sidelined or ignored, or called unreasonable.  Yet as George Bernard Shaw noted in one of my favorite quotes "All progress depends on the unreasonable man.  A reasonable man (or woman) will adapt themselves to the world." 

It may be that the people who will become most important to you are those who have been sidelined or ignored in the past, or people not on your team today who bring an entirely new set of skills to bear.  Either way, you need to change how you think about your workforce.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

A peek at Trump's last two years

Executives: narrow your focus for success

The startup serenity prayer