A few trillion here, a few trillion there
Word came last week from the Congressional Budget Office that the United States debt has reached $40 trillion dollars. Or, a number roughly equivalent to the country's GDP. In other countries, when their outstanding debt reaches or exceeds their GDP, the IMF and other international organizations step in to help manage inflation and the declining value of the local currency. So far, no international body has stepped in to help the US, and I doubt help will come, because our economy continues to grow and I think we have enough international credit to manage our debt load. At least we do right now.
The title of this post refers to a possibly apocryphal quote from a former US senator, who was complaining about federal spending. He is reported to have said, "a billion here and a billion there and soon you are talking about real money". If the quote actually occurred, it seems almost quaint using today's figures. A billion here or there is what we pay on the interest of our current debt every 8 hours.
Our debt has effectively doubled starting from Trump's first term in office, running through the Biden administration and halfway through the second Trump administration. Less than 10 years ago, our outstanding debt was approximately $17T. How did it accelerate so quickly in such a short period of time? Tax cuts, spending increases, wars and Covid are the best answers.
According to the CBO, the government's support for the economy during Covid drove at least a third of the growth in the debt. The government was more concerned - quite rightly - with sustaining a reasonable economy and household income during the dramatic impact that Covid had on the global economy. The challenge with the investment to keep the economy running is that, several years on, we've never paid the money back.
Tax cuts, like the One Big Beautiful Bill, and spending increases have also contributed to the increase in the debt. When we both reduce the amount of income coming into the government and spend more on existing and new programs and entitlements without adding taxes, we borrow from our future, or, more accurately, our children's future.
Wheelbarrows full of cash
What we could face, in a deep recession, is what the Germans faced after World War I. Inflation was so high that thousands of marks were required to purchase a loaf of bread. You'd need a wheelbarrow full of cash to buy a single loaf of bread at the peak of inflation. In some instances, their currency was so debased that it was more beneficial to burn currency than to use it as a medium of exchange. This inflation and its misery led to the anger that spawned the Hitler administration and the Second World War.
Now, the US isn't likely to tip into recession or inflation at that rate, but perhaps another warning bell or two is warranted.
Warning bell #1 - Debt Service
As anyone with a credit card knows, when you borrow, you pay interest. With over $40 Trillion in debt, our government pays a substantial amount of interest. If we break out debt service as a line item in the federal budget, we spend more on interest payments on our debt than we do anything else the government pays for, other than Social Security and Medicare/Medicaid. We spend more on paying off the interest on our debt than we do on the Department of Defense, which is typically the largest budget item after Social Security and Medicare/Medicaid. And these payments aren't paying down the principal of our debt, just paying the interest.
Warning bell #2 - An aging population
We had less to worry about when we had a younger population and higher population growth. To maintain the population, each couple needs to replace themselves and a little more - science tells us that 2.1 is roughly the replacement rate to sustain a population. In the US, we are below replacement rate, meaning that without immigration, or a new baby boom, our population will shrink. And if the population shrinks, taxes are likely to shrink as well, making it more difficult to pay back all that debt.
Additionally, while we aren't reproducing at a sustainable rate, our population is aging, and an aging population requires more services than a younger, healthier population. Demands for programs like Medicare and Medicaid will only increase and other programs which cover costs for the elderly will grow as the boomers retire. But we've known this for years.
Warning bell #3 - Demands on social security
As people age, they retire and rely on their savings, 401Ks and social security. Social Security was set up as a safety net to provide approximately 40% of an individual's salary, to ensure that individuals had some income in retirement. However, Social Security does not act like a savings account. While all of us who work pay into Social Security, those savings aren't going into the stock market or bank accounts, but are quickly turned around to pay the benefits of living social security recipients. And, as or if the population shrinks and fewer people join the workforce, there are fewer people paying into Social Security just as a large contingent of people retire. So, fewer younger people are going to be paying to Social Security just as a lot of older people start demanding their payments.
There is a good chance that the existing program will have to start paying out less than retirees expect within the next decade, which will lead to a lot of older retirees demanding what they paid in, and a lot of younger citizens wondering if there will be anything left for them.
Programs like Social Security work on the fact that people trust that they will be taken care of. If the younger population starts to believe that they are paying in and won't see any benefits, they will demand change, and we could see the start of an interesting "war" - younger, employed people versus their grandparents.
Warning bell #4 - a new generation entering politics
There is a new generation entering politics and demanding to be taken seriously. Younger politicians (and some older ones like Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren) are shifting the traditional economic models, moving toward more government provision with potentially more taxes. As/if this group gains political strength, the basis of our government, taxation and economy could change. We do not know all of the implications and they aren't necessarily bad. But Wall Street and the investor class hate uncertainty, and this much change will cause some decline in investments.
Deficits as far as the eye can see
In 2026, the US Federal deficit (the amount we spend more than we take in) will be approximately $2 Trillion dollars. The CBO says the federal income is rising at a 3% rate year on year, while spending is rising at a 5% rate, year on year. We need to, at a minimum, flip those percentages.
Time to live within our means
It's time, actually past time, for the US government to live within its means. We need to freeze our spending at worst and allow the GDP to grow and to hopefully bring in more tax income in order to cover our demands and start to pay down some of our debt or at least bring the debt to GDP ratio down under 100%. The best possible outcome is to freeze spending and grow the economy. This approach is unlikely to work, as noted in a Fortune magazine article online from August 2026.
The second option is to cut programs and/or raise taxes to cover any increases in spending or shortfalls in revenue. Conservatives do not like to increase taxes and liberals do not like to decrease spending, but until or unless we rationalize how we as a nation pay for the things we want AND start to reduce our debt, we leave behind a terrible mess for people in their 20s and 30s.
Worse, change in income or outgo should not be made on the backs of promises to older populations. It does not seem right to promise people some income in retirement only to change the rules. The vast majority of Social Security recipients paid into the system and should not be short changed, so we need to find other programs to cut or other taxes to raise.
We also need to balance the use of new taxes to cover our debts and most important programs but be careful not to raise taxes to the point where work becomes a disincentive or companies and individuals pull back on investment. One goal needs to be to grow the economic engine so that the economy grows, shrinking the debt to GDP ratio.
A decades long problem requires a decades long solution
These problems were not created overnight. As noted, from about the Clinton Administration to the first Trump Administration, we've generated about $20 trillion in debt. The problem is the significant surge in debt in the last decade. We need a concentrated program to focus on growing the economy, paying down the debt, focusing investment in the most important programs and freezing programs at status quo levels while we start paying down our debt. This is not an overnight solution, but it is one with the right leadership, either from the politicians (which is unlikely) or the people (more likely) can and will happen.
John F Kennedy introduced the idea of landing a man on the moon and returning him safely to Earth a decade before we could safely accomplish the task. We need a similar vision and a longer-term commitment to get our debt under control, before it controls us.
A problem hidden in plain sight
In an emperor's clothing scenario, it's not like any of this is a secret. What is puzzling is how little focus it is getting and what a significant lack of urgency seems to be emerging. We risk moving from a linear increase in debt to an arithmetic increase in our debt in just a few years. Getting too far behind this curve will make it increasingly difficult to catch up.
As I said, everyone knows this, yet no one seems overly concerned. Oh, the Concord Coalition creates reports and some good governance types raise it. It used to be that the republican party cared about the debt limits, but now it seems no one does. What's really going on is that no one wants to point out the issue, recognizing it will create significant work to fix and refocusing on how we tax and spend.
The time for talking is over
We've talked about addressing the federal deficit and debt for years. We've kicked the can down the road. As with most significant and potentially painful changes, we won't address the problem unless or until it becomes too severe to ignore any longer. We are rapidly approaching that point, the point where our debt will force our elected representatives to make choices that none of us want to make, either reducing entitlements to seniors, or cutting major programs, or reducing spending on defense, or raising taxes, or possibly all of the above.
The good news is that we don't have to pay off all of our debt, just bring the debt down to reasonable levels (say 60% of GDP). We can accomplish this by slowing spending, encouraging growth in the economy and some tax increases. No one group or organization should be directly targeted, and everyone needs to pitch in in order to right the financial ship.
Comments
Post a Comment