A nation of consumers. What could go wrong?
I spent time this weekend in a hospital, visiting a family member. One thing that struck me was how quickly everyone reached for their phones whenever the conversation lagged. Of course, talking in a hospital room, where the patient is often drowsy or sleeping, or a doctor or nurse is constantly barging in, is difficult at best. Plus, people are accustomed to looking at their phones for updates on their email, Teams, Slack and of course a host of messaging and social media apps.
The hypnotic gaze that proceeds as people scan and scroll is interesting and somewhat disheartening. We are becoming, more and more, a nation of consumers, especially of digital content, and that has some challenging implications.
First, it means that we are all getting information, news, provocation and other content from the channels we elect to view and are often ignoring other channels. There are so many information channels, so many social media influencers and experts that even having an off-line coversation about the same topic with someone who shares a slightly different point of view or who reads different social media platforms is like debating water with a Martian. There's often almost no point of overlap on the same issue and no realization that there are definitive facts and then shades of those facts. We lack a shared perspective on what is happening, what facts matter and in some cases what is real and what has been edited or fabricated. There are several worries packed into this one paragraph, namely that it's difficult to establish what is real or true, and secondly that so many people are sorted into so many different factions, who are only consuming a small portion of the spectrum of information about any issue.
Second, when we consume, especially on social media, we become grazers of the information provided, signaling to the app to continue to provide more stories and information tailored to what we've read. The Google Bubble is real, but the social media and information bubble is even more troubling. Social media exists to make you an infinite consumer of information, to anger, amuse and provoke you into reading more. We have encountered Alice going down the rabbit hole. Which leads to other rabbit holes but never a conclusion.
Third, and I think most important, is that all the time spent consuming and scrolling is lost to what we could be doing - creating. The more you consume, the less time and energy, and willpower, you have for creating. And in this instance, I am talking about creating digital content if you must but also creating art or music with your mind and your hands. Or working in your yard, to create a beautiful garden. Twenty years ago, a noted sociologist wrote about Bowling Alone, and the decline of civic engagement in societies and groups. Increasingly, we are losing hobbies and actions that require deep involvement and investment away from the PC, from social media. Will watching one more Tik Tok video lead you to create the next symphony? Were you even able to write a symphony? Who knows, but if you spend all your time on Tik Tok, you'll never try.
Finally, all this consumption leads to a resignation. That is, we are all seeing what seems beautiful and effortless in all of this social media. People do elaborate dances without a hitch. Beauty influencers show how incredible they can look in only minutes. Social media promotes a fantasy world where everything can be fixed or cured in minutes, whereas in reality, the fixes aren't permanent and take far more time to develop, produce and curate. But so many people watching and consuming this social media feel inadequate, thinking they could never measure up and fail to try. We lose our sense of experimentation, knowing we cannot match what we see on the screen. So, rather than try, we go deeper into the matrix.
What happens when all we want to do is consume? If we are all consumers, where are the producers? Where are the people who actually invent, investigate, experiment, fail and try again? If we are all consumers, who are the people who are actually learning and creating? More importantly, if all your information shows that people are always successful, always dance perfectly, always win the argument, will people be willing to risk trying something new and failing?
When I was younger, we worried that the US would be left behind by deep Soviet scientific research, and we doubled down on science and engineering, with outcomes like going to the moon. Now, we are entertained by cage fighting at the White House, dance offs on Tik Tok, and a decreasing sense of purpose, looking askance at intelligence and the pursuit of excellence, and asking each other about some influencer's point of view about an arcane topic, rather than creating something new of our own.
The more we consume, whether in terms of videos or music or social media, the less engaged and less creative we become. The US was once a nation of producers. Look no further than Carl Sandberg's poem about Chicago: Hog Butcher, tool maker, stacker of wheat, player with railroads...
As any economy or market matures, services and information will likely become more important than produced tangible goods. But what happens when we raise generations who are mostly if not completely familiar with consumption without concerning themselves or worrying about production?
Can we outsource all of our meaningful work, all of our production, to other people or countries? Even if we could, what do we lose?
Comments
Post a Comment